Papua’s Noken System: Tradition Meets Democracy

In several highland communities of Papua, the familiar image of an election is different from the one seen in most Indonesian polling stations. Instead of every voter entering a private booth to mark a ballot, community members may gather through customary deliberations, reach a collective agreement, and entrust the delivery of their political choice to a tribal chief or traditional leader. This practice, known as the Noken system, represents a distinctive encounter between Indigenous Papuan traditions and Indonesia’s modern electoral framework.
Named after the traditional woven bag used by Papuan communities in everyday life, the Noken system carries meanings that extend beyond its physical form. The bag is associated with family life, cultural identity, and communal relationships. In electoral practice, it has become a symbol of collective choice, customary agreement, and trust in traditional leadership.
For communities that continue to observe this tradition, political decisions are not always understood as individual acts detached from social relationships. They may instead emerge through discussion, consensus, and the authority of customary institutions.
Indonesia has recognized the Noken system within its constitutional framework, particularly through the Constitutional Court’s landmark Decision No. 47-81/PHPU.A-VII/2009. However, this recognition is not a blanket exemption from electoral law. Its application is restricted to areas with an established tradition of using the system, and election organizers are expected to ensure that the process respects the rights of eligible voters.
The historical discussion surrounding Noken is sometimes linked to the 1969 Act of Free Choice, known in Indonesia as Pepera. Both involve collective decision-making and consultation with representatives, but they are not the same electoral mechanism. The distinction is essential to understanding Papua’s political history and the evolution of its electoral practices.

What Is the Noken System?
A traditional bag becomes a symbol of collective choice

Noken is a traditional Papuan bag made by weaving natural fibers, including fibers obtained from tree bark and other plant materials. It is used to carry agricultural produce, personal belongings, and, in some communities, even babies.
Beyond its practical function, the bag has cultural and symbolic significance. It represents relationships between people, their environment, and their customary way of life.
The Elections Supervisory Agency (Bawaslu), in an explanatory article published on October 27, 2026, described Noken as a symbol of people’s votes, unity, and collective agreement. It also associated the tradition with values such as cooperation, peace, mutual trust, and deliberation.
When used in elections, the bag becomes a representation of the community’s political choice. Rather than treating voting exclusively as an individual procedure, the practice can reflect a decision reached through customary consultation.
The approach is particularly associated with parts of Papua, where traditional leadership and community deliberation remain important features of social organization.
However, Noken is used only in some parts of Papua. Nor does every polling station in a regency where the tradition exists automatically conduct elections through this method.

Two main patterns of Noken voting
Indonesian electoral institutions and legal discussions generally describe two principal patterns: the Noken Bigman system and the communal or collective-consensus approach.
The first, known as Noken Bigman, involves the delegation of a community’s political choice to a tribal chief or recognized traditional leader. The leader is entrusted with communicating or representing the collective preference in the electoral process.
This arrangement reflects the influence of customary leadership in communities where a tribal chief may be regarded as a representative of shared interests.
The second pattern, often called Noken Komunal, is based on collective deliberation. Community members discuss the available candidates or political parties and seek agreement before the result is recorded through the Noken mechanism.
The distinction matters because collective agreement and delegated representation are not necessarily identical. In a communal process, participation in discussion is central. In the Bigman model, the authority entrusted to the traditional leader plays a more prominent role.
The practical details can also vary between communities. For that reason, the system should not be treated as a single uniform procedure applied in exactly the same way throughout the highlands.

How Noken Became Part of Indonesia’s Electoral Framework
From customary practice to legal recognition

The Noken tradition developed within communities that already had established methods of reaching collective decisions. Its use in elections emerged from the interaction between these customary practices and the formal electoral system.
According to a legal article published by the Legal Documentation and Information Network of Indonesia’s Audit Board (BPK) on April 15, 2026, customary Noken voting has been practiced in parts of Papua since 1971.
The practice uses deliberation with traditional elders and community representatives. In some areas, ballots are represented or delivered through tribal leaders, while other communities use hanging bags to indicate the agreed political choice.
The same BPK article identifies two constitutional and legal foundations that are central to understanding the system.
The first is Article 18B, paragraph (2) of Indonesia’s 1945 Constitution. It recognizes and respects customary law communities and their traditional rights, provided that they remain relevant to social development and consistent with the principles of the Unitary State of the Republic of Indonesia.
The second is Constitutional Court Decision No. 47-81/PHPU.A-VII/2009.
The ruling became a major reference point for recognizing the importance of customary values in electoral administration. It acknowledged that election procedures in certain Papuan communities could not be assessed without considering their established traditions and local social structures.
This recognition illustrates how Indonesia’s constitutional system can accommodate local customs within a national democratic framework.
It also establishes an important principle: cultural recognition and electoral accountability must operate together.

The Constitutional Court’s 2009 decision
The Constitutional Court’s 2009 ruling emerged from an electoral dispute involving the use of Noken in Papua.
The case brought attention to a voting practice that differed from the standard ballot procedure used in most other parts of Indonesia.
Rather than dismissing the customary system simply because it was different, the Court considered the social and cultural circumstances in which it operated.
The decision became a legal reference for recognizing customary electoral practices in areas where Noken had been used continuously.
This did not mean that any community could introduce the system at will or that traditional leaders could automatically determine the political choices of all residents.
Subsequent legal and administrative guidance has stressed the importance of continuity of customary practice, clear territorial boundaries, and supervision by election organizers.
The principle is therefore one of limited recognition rather than unrestricted application.

Where Is the Noken System Used Today?
Papua Tengah and Papua Pegunungan

According to Bawaslu’s October 2026 explanation, the Noken system is currently associated with selected areas in two Indonesian provinces: Papua Tengah (Central Papua) and Papua Pegunungan (Highland Papua).
In Papua Tengah, the listed regencies are Puncak Jaya, Intan Jaya, Deiyai, Dogiyai, Puncak, and Paniai.
In Papua Pegunungan, the listed regencies are Jayawijaya, Lanny Jaya, Nduga, Tolikara, Mamberamo Tengah, and Yahukimo.
However, the existence of the tradition at the regency level does not mean that every polling station uses Noken. The designated polling stations are determined through decisions issued by the relevant election commission.
This restriction is important for ensuring that the system remains connected to established customary practices rather than becoming a general alternative to individual voting.
The KPU’s 2025 explanatory article on Noken in Mamberamo Tengah also identifies several highland regencies where the practice has historically been used, including Mamberamo Tengah, Tolikara, Jayawijaya, Lanny Jaya, and Puncak Jaya.
The geographical context helps explain why local electoral arrangements have developed differently from those in more accessible urban areas.
Papua’s mountainous terrain, dispersed settlements, and transport limitations can make the organization of elections particularly demanding. In some locations, reaching communities and distributing electoral materials require extensive logistical planning.
These conditions are relevant to understanding why customary deliberation has remained significant in certain communities.
Nevertheless, geography alone does not explain every aspect of the system. Its continued use is also connected to local political culture, customary authority, and community preferences.

Pepera 1969: A Historical Process That Must Be Distinguished from Noken
Collective consultation during the Act of Free Choice

The Noken system is sometimes presented as a direct historical precedent for the 1969 Act of Free Choice, or Pepera (Penentuan Pendapat Rakyat), because both involve collective decision-making and the participation of representatives.
There are similarities in the broader principle of consultation, but the historical record does not support describing Pepera as an implementation of the modern Noken electoral system.
The United Nations Yearbook of 1969 provides an important contemporary record of the process.
According to the publication, the UN representative had proposed a mixed approach for the Act of Free Choice. The proposal included a one-person, one-vote procedure in more accessible coastal areas and collective consultations, known as musyawarah, with representatives in the less accessible interior.
The Indonesian government subsequently informed the UN representative that it intended to use eight representative councils, which would be enlarged to become consultative assemblies. These councils would reach their decisions through collective deliberation.
Consultations on the proposed procedure took place in March and April 1969 in the presence of the UN team. The councils approved the proposed method, according to the UN Yearbook’s account.
The Act of Free Choice was then conducted between July 14 and August 2, 1969.
The UN record states that the enlarged councils contained a total of 1,026 members, who were asked to pronounce themselves on behalf of the population on whether Irian Barat (West Irian/Papua), also known as Netherlands New Guinea, should remain with Indonesia or sever its ties with the country.
All the enlarged councils unanimously declared in favor of remaining with Indonesia.
The figure of 1,026 is the number recorded in the UN Yearbook. Some other historical publications cite different totals, including 1,022, illustrating why the figures should be attributed to their respective sources rather than presented as interchangeable.

What the United Nations recorded
The UN Yearbook also notes objections regarding the political environment in which the process took place.
It mentions that the Secretary-General referred to concerns raised by his representative concerning the implementation of Article XXII of the 1962 New York Agreement, specifically the provisions regarding freedom of speech, movement, and assembly.
The representative observed that these rights had not been fully implemented and that the administration exercised strict political control over the population, ostensibly to guard against intervention by the Dutch, who sought to retain influence in Papua (Irian Barat).
At the same time, the UN Yearbook records the representative’s conclusion that, notwithstanding geographical limitations and the general political situation, an “Act of Free Choice” had been carried out in accordance with the practices of Indonesia and the people of Papua, with the representatives expressing a desire for Irian Barat to remain part of Indonesia.
The General Assembly subsequently considered the Secretary-General’s report and adopted Resolution 2504 (XXIV) on November 19, 1969. The resolution took note of the report and acknowledged with appreciation the fulfillment of the tasks entrusted to the Secretary-General and his representatives under the 1962 Agreement.
These historical details should be presented together. They explain the official process and its recorded outcome while also acknowledging the reservations documented by the United Nations itself.
It would therefore be inaccurate to describe the 1969 process simply as a Noken election. The documented procedure was based on representative councils and musyawarah, while the customary Noken electoral practice is recorded in later periods, beginning in 1971.
The two processes share a broader connection with collective deliberation, but they have distinct historical and institutional contexts.

Noken and the Meaning of Democracy in Papua
Customary leadership and collective deliberation

For supporters of the Noken system, its significance lies in the relationship between political participation and customary institutions.
In some Papuan communities, traditional leaders are entrusted with responsibilities that extend beyond ceremonial functions. They may help resolve disputes, represent collective interests, and facilitate decisions affecting the wider community.
Within this social structure, collective deliberation can be viewed as a legitimate way of expressing political preferences.
Bawaslu’s October 2026 explanation identifies several democratic values associated with Noken: social participation, cooperation, deliberation, and trust in local leadership.
The KPU’s Yalimo office similarly describes the system as a distinctive form of political participation rooted in local traditions.
These institutional perspectives underline the importance of recognizing that democratic practices can take different forms across diverse societies.
Indonesia’s constitutional framework provides space for customary institutions while maintaining the national commitment to democratic elections.

The challenge of protecting individual voting rights
However, the Noken system also raises questions that cannot be ignored.
A 2021 academic article by Muhammad Malikul Lubbi, published in Dharmasisya, the postgraduate law journal of the University of Indonesia’s Faculty of Law, examined the relationship between Noken voting and national democratic principles.
The study identified two principal patterns: the representation of tribal members’ choices by traditional leaders and the use of Noken bags as substitutes for ballot boxes.
It also raised concerns about whether collective voting arrangements could restrict an individual’s freedom to choose according to personal conscience.
The BPK’s legal analysis published in April 2026 similarly acknowledged that the Noken system does not provide every individual with the same direct, free, and secret voting procedure found in conventional polling arrangements.
This is a central constitutional challenge.
The recognition of customary practices should not become a justification for coercion, intimidation, or the suppression of individual political preferences.
For Noken to remain consistent with democratic principles, deliberation must be genuine. Community members should be able to participate without pressure, and the process must be monitored to ensure that the resulting choice reflects a legitimate community agreement.
The involvement of KPU and Bawaslu is therefore essential. Election organizers have a responsibility to ensure that cultural recognition is accompanied by transparency, accountability, and protection of voters’ rights.

The Role of KPU and Bawaslu in Safeguarding the Process
The implementation of Noken requires coordination between election administrators, traditional leaders, and local communities.
The General Elections Commission (KPU) is responsible for determining the polling stations that may use the system in accordance with applicable decisions and technical guidance.
Bawaslu, meanwhile, supervises the electoral process and monitors potential violations.
The 2024 election regulations and decisions provide more specific guidance on the areas where customary arrangements can be used. Bawaslu’s 2026 explanation refers to KPU Decision No. 66 of 2024 on technical guidelines for voting and vote counting, as well as Papua Pegunungan KPU Decision No. 70 of 2024 concerning polling stations permitted to use Noken, Ikat, or consensus-based voting in the 2024 simultaneous elections.
These rules are intended to prevent the system from being applied beyond areas with an established tradition.
Supervision also helps address concerns about the influence of traditional leaders and the possibility of disputes over the interpretation of community agreements.
For election administrators, the challenge is to understand local customs while ensuring that all procedures remain consistent with the law.
This requires more than simply placing a Noken bag at a polling station. It involves clear communication with communities, accurate voter data, the participation of authorized representatives, and effective monitoring.

Preserving Cultural Heritage While Strengthening Democracy
The Noken system offers a wider lesson about the relationship between cultural diversity and democratic governance.
Indonesia is home to many customary communities whose traditions shape social organization and collective decision-making. Recognizing these traditions can strengthen public participation when they are accommodated within a clear constitutional framework.
In Papua, Noken reflects a political culture in which customary deliberation and community leadership remain influential in selected highland areas.
At the same time, democratic institutions must continue to ensure that collective traditions do not override the fundamental rights of individual citizens.
The future of the system will depend on maintaining that balance.
Education about electoral rights, transparent customary deliberations, clear administrative rules, and effective supervision can help ensure that Noken remains a meaningful expression of local culture without undermining democratic accountability.
The process also provides an opportunity for younger generations to understand both the cultural significance of Noken and the responsibilities that come with participating in elections.

Conclusion
The Noken system represents a distinctive form of electoral practice in parts of Papua, where customary deliberation, collective agreement, and traditional leadership remain important elements of community life.
Its recognition by Indonesia’s Constitutional Court in 2009 demonstrated that the national legal framework can accommodate established local traditions. Its continued application in designated areas of Papua Tengah and Papua Pegunungan shows how customary institutions can remain relevant within modern electoral administration.
However, the historical relationship between Noken and Pepera 1969 requires careful distinction. The Act of Free Choice used representative councils and musyawarah, with 1,026 members recorded by the United Nations, while the documented Noken electoral practice emerged in subsequent years.
That distinction does not diminish the cultural importance of Noken. Instead, it places the tradition within its proper historical context.
For Papua, the long-term challenge is to preserve the values of deliberation, unity, and customary leadership while strengthening the rights of every eligible voter.
A democratic system becomes more resilient when it respects local identity and protects individual freedoms at the same time. In that balance lies the continuing significance of Noken in Indonesia’s diverse democratic landscape.

Read Also
Noken: The Living Philosophy of Papua’s Heritage
New York Agreement and Papua’s Political History

Related posts

TNI Arrests Four Suspects in Keerom, Including Murder Fugitive

Kodaeral X Foils Cannabis Smuggling in Jayapura

Yahukimo Civilian Killing: Police Probe TPNPB Suspects